Two Boys Convicted Of Horrific Mistaken Identity Stabbing That Claimed Life Of Mohammed Hassan Ali
- Jason King
- Jul 26, 2024
- 3 min read
Hi and welcome to this JK B'HAM Crime Report for VPN: REGIONAL NETWORKS:

In a tragic incident that has shocked Birmingham, two 15-year-old boys have been convicted for the senseless killing of Muhammad Ali, an innocent 17-year-old who was in the wrong place at the wrong time. The convictions come after an investigation revealed the boys followed and confronted Muhammad and his friend, mistakenly believing they were involved in an earlier attack.
On January 20, Muhammad and his friend were enjoying a hot chocolate at the Little Dessert Shop in the Bullring before heading to Victoria Square. There, they were confronted by the two boys, who demanded to know if they were responsible for an attack on one of their friends. Despite Muhammad's protests that they were not involved, one of the boys pulled out a large knife and fatally stabbed him in the chest.
Muhammad was rushed to Birmingham’s Queen Elizabeth Hospital, but the damage to his heart was too severe, and he was pronounced dead at 6:40 PM. The swift response by the police, who tracked the suspects through CCTV, led to their arrest on January 23. One boy has been convicted of murder and possession of a knife, while the other has been convicted of manslaughter and possession of a bladed article. They will be sentenced in October.
Det Insp Michelle Thurgood, who led the investigation, expressed deep concern over the rise in knife crime. “Sadly, this is another case of young men carrying a knife and being willing to use it with catastrophic consequences. Muhammad had simply been enjoying a day out with a friend. There’s no evidence at all that he knew either of the boys who went on to kill him, and no evidence he was involved in any earlier attack.”
Police are under no illusions about the scale of the challenge they face. Det Insp Thurgood described it as "horrific" that the boy was carrying "such a large knife" around Birmingham city centre during the day. “It is frightening that youths think it is acceptable and don’t think twice about the consequences of their actions—not only on the victim but on themselves and any other witnesses," she said.
Insp Colin Gallier, who works on an anti-knife crime initiative, echoed these concerns, noting that the issue among young people in the city is an "ongoing challenge." He stated, “It’s truly concerning that we’ve got a high rate of young people in our communities carrying knives and it’s something that West Midlands Police is fully aware of.”
This senseless act of violence has left the community worried about the safety of its young people. The shocking callousness and disregard for life shown by a small minority highlight the urgent need for comprehensive measures to address knife crime.
The West Midlands Police's Project Guardian aims to tackle this issue with dedicated patrols and educational programs to dissuade young people from carrying knives. However, Det Insp Thurgood emphasized the importance of community involvement: “We need help from parents, guardians, teachers—anyone who cares for young people. I’d urge them to share Muhammad’s story with the young people in their lives and to really consider the devastating consequences it has had for everyone involved.”
As Birmingham mourns the loss of Muhammad Ali, the community remains on edge, hoping for a future where such tragedies can be prevented.
Well, that’s all for now. But until our next article, please stay tuned, stay informed, but most of all stay safe, and I’ll see you then.
Jason King
Birmingham City-Desk
Twitter (X) @JasonKingNews
Comments